NEW

PCSMANTRA.COM · Study Article

Corporal punishment persists in Indian classrooms despite the RTE Section 17 ban

Published: 16 November 2026
Prelims: polity

Original symbolic illustration for the corporal punishment debate in schools
Original symbolic illustration: pcsmantra.com

16 November 2026: Police in Kozhikode, Kerala, have registered a case against a teacher for allegedly caning a 10-year-old Class 5 student (reported 15 November). Around the same time, a Hindu explainer asked why corporal punishment persists in Indian classrooms more than 15 years after the ban, citing WHO, Ministry of Women and Child Development and NGO survey data.

Legal framework (verified facts)

  • Section 17, RTE Act 2009: physical punishment and mental harassment of children in educational institutions are prohibited - an explicit statutory ban.
  • Child rights: the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child and monitoring by national/state child rights commissions (NCPCR/SCPCR); in the Kerala case, the father approached the state SCPCR.

Studies and data

  • 'Child Abuse in India - 2007' (Ministry of Women and Child Development): two out of three schoolchildren reported facing corporal punishment.
  • Agrasar (NGO) survey, Gurugram 2018: 80% of students from marginalised communities reported such punishment from teachers - a clear caste/class dimension.
  • WHO report: corporal punishment overloads the nervous, cardiovascular and nutritional systems, changes brain structure and function, causes mental health issues and impairs cognitive and socio-emotional development.

Why it persists

  • Cultural legitimacy: the "discipline" culture normalises violence; threats from teachers (such as failing students) suppress complaints.
  • Weak enforcement: despite Section 17, school-level grievance mechanisms and monitoring remain inadequate; managements often shield teachers.
  • Alternatives missing: gaps in positive discipline and teacher training point to the policy direction.

Quiz: Test your knowledge

Q1: Consider on corporal punishment: 1. Section 17 of the RTE Act 2009 prohibits it 2. The MWCD 'Child Abuse in India 2007' study found two-thirds of children faced it 3. The Agrasar 2018 survey covered Kolkata schools. Which are correct?

(a) 1 and 2 only
(b) 1 and 3 only
(c) 2 and 3 only
(d) 1, 2 and 3

Answer and explanation: (a) The Agrasar 2018 survey was in Gurugram schools, not Kolkata - statement 3 is wrong.

Q2: Which provision in India prohibits physical punishment and mental harassment of children in schools?

(a) IPC Section 302
(b) Section 17 of the RTE Act 2009
(c) The Labour Act 2013
(d) The RTI Act 2005

Answer and explanation: (b) Section 17 of the Right to Education Act 2009 explicitly prohibits physical punishment and mental harassment.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

In short: Amid a case of a 10-year-old being caned in Kozhikode, a new report notes corporal punishment continues despite the Section 17 ban; MWCD 2007 found two-thirds of children affected; WHO flags long-term effects on brain development.

Question: What is the legal position on corporal punishment in Indian schools?

Section 17 of the RTE Act 2009 prohibits both physical punishment and mental harassment in educational institutions - a complete statutory ban.

Question: What effects of corporal punishment have been reported?

Per WHO: overloading of nervous, cardiovascular and nutritional systems, changes in brain structure and function, mental health issues, and impaired cognitive and socio-emotional development.

Question: What happened in the Kozhikode case?

On 6 November, a teacher in Kerala's Kozhikode allegedly caned a 10-year-old Class 5 girl in front of classmates; police registered a case and the father also complained to the state child rights commission.

Sources:

Download this article: PDF (English)